Sales alone don't determine whether a vending location is profitable. Operators need to examine margins, commissions, service costs and inventory losses before deciding whether to renew, renegotiate or relocate.

November 20, 2026 by Richard Slawsky — Editor, Connect Media
A vending machine can generate steady sales and still be a poor investment. Between product costs, location commissions, service visits and unsold inventory, an apparently successful location may contribute little to an operator's bottom line.
Contract renewal offers an opportunity to examine the numbers and determine whether a location deserves continued investment, operational changes or an exit.
Zach Lewis, founder of Coin and Claw, a St. Louis-area company that places trading card vending machines in high-traffic businesses, said the decision begins with determining whether a machine earns enough to justify its operating requirements.
"I start by asking whether the location is pulling its weight after product costs, commissions and service," Lewis said in an email interview. "There's no single sales number I use for every machine. A location that's easy to service can be worth keeping at a lower sales volume than one that takes a dedicated trip."
Here are five numbers operators should examine before signing another location agreement.
Gross sales provide the starting point, but operators should examine trends, seasonal fluctuations and revenue per machine.
The National Automatic Merchandising Association's 2024–25 industry census puts average annual revenue at about $7,000 per machine, including smart coolers. Actual sales vary widely by type of location and size of the operator.
A location generating $2,000 monthly may appear attractive, but that figure means little without considering operating expenses. A smaller account producing $1,200 with fewer service requirements could deliver a better return.
Operators should review at least 12 months of sales data, comparing performance with previous periods and similar locations. They should also identify which products drive sales and whether declines reflect seasonal conditions or changing customer preferences.
Lewis said timing matters when evaluating performance.
"A slow month during a location's usual off-season means something different from a steady decline in products that normally sell well," he said.
A sustained decline may justify changes to merchandise, pricing or equipment before an operator abandons the location.
Matt Buckley, founder of U.K. procurement consultancy Caventis, suggested checking whether the location still serves the same customer base. He pointed to a December 2024 report to Florida's State Committee of Vendors that said sales at a Miami airport vending operation fell 50% after a parole program closed. Three snack machines were removed from the area. When demand drops, Buckley said, an operator may be able to keep the account by reducing the number of machines.
Revenue does not equal profit. Product margins reveal how much of each sale remains after merchandise costs.
For example, a product purchased for $1 and sold for $2 generates a 50% gross margin before commissions and operating expenses. If the purchase cost rises to $1.50, the margin falls to 25%.
Operators should calculate margins by product category rather than relying solely on overall averages. High-volume products with weak margins may contribute less to profitability than slower-selling merchandise with stronger margins.
Zach Lewis recalled a location with substantial foot traffic and younger customers where higher-priced trading cards struggled to sell.
"One location had good foot traffic and drew a younger crowd. The machine was getting plenty of exposure, but some of my higher-priced products barely moved," he said.
Rather than relocating, Lewis adjusted the merchandise.
"I swapped those products for more affordable options and lowered some prices a little. Sales started to improve after the change," Lewis said.
The experience demonstrated that disappointing sales do not necessarily indicate a poor location. Sometimes the merchandise simply doesn't match customers' purchasing preferences.
Commissions can turn a profitable account into a marginal one, particularly as product costs, processing fees and labor expenses increase. Location agreements may require operators to pay a percentage of gross sales, a fixed monthly fee or both.
For example, a machine generating $2,000 in monthly sales with a 15% commission produces a $300 payment to the property owner. Increasing that commission to 20% raises the payment to $400, reducing the operator's monthly contribution by $100.
Over a year, that difference amounts to $1,200.
Before renewing, operators should determine whether the commission structure reflects the location's sales potential and operating requirements. A high-traffic site with dependable access and consistent customer demand may justify a higher commission than one with limited traffic or difficult servicing conditions.
Operators also can negotiate alternatives, including longer contract terms, better machine placement or permission to adjust prices. The objective is to establish terms that remain financially sustainable for both parties.
Service expenses are frequently underestimated because operators focus on time spent at the machine rather than the entire trip.
A proper calculation includes travel time, mileage, restocking, cleaning, troubleshooting and repairs. Operators also should consider whether a machine can be serviced alongside others on an established route.
Zach Lewis said some of his trading card machines are nearly an hour away in each direction, making route planning essential.
"I look at the whole trip. That includes drive time, mileage, time spent restocking or troubleshooting, and any parts I need for a repair," he said.
He coordinates visits to reduce unnecessary travel.
"If I'm heading out there for a repair, I bring what I need to restock the other machines while I'm in the area," he said. "That can save me another two-hour round trip a few days later."
He also uses larger machines at distant locations to carry more inventory and reduce service frequency.
"I expect those farther-out machines to perform above my usual baseline because they take more time to support," he said.
Operators can calculate monthly service expenses by multiplying total labor hours by an hourly cost and adding mileage, repairs and other direct expenses. Dividing that total by monthly sales yields a service cost percentage for comparing locations.
Buckley said the service calculation also should include preparation, loading and parking. Operators who service their own machines should assign an hourly cost to their time.
Evan Lewis, managing director of equipment lender Gusto Finance, suggested dividing a location's contribution after operating costs by the total hours spent servicing it, including travel. That comparison can show whether a smaller account close to the route earns more per service hour than a busier one that requires a detour.
Access also matters. Zach Lewis said difficult relationships with location personnel can reduce an account's value.
"If it's consistently hard to get access or coordinate service, that eats into what the location is worth," he said.
For those selling fresh food and other perishables, spoilage can significantly reduce profitability. Operators should track the cost of expired and damaged merchandise, identify products that consistently go unsold and determine whether restocking quantities exceed demand.
For example, a machine with $1,500 in monthly sales that discards $150 worth of merchandise at purchase cost loses the equivalent of 10% of sales to spoilage. Reducing delivery quantities, adjusting service schedules or changing merchandise may improve profitability.
Nonperishable products present a related challenge: Slow-moving inventory ties up cash and occupies machine capacity.
Zach Lewis said trading cards don't carry the same spoilage risks as food, but demand can decline.
"Interest can still fade, and slow inventory ties up cash and takes up a slot I could use for something that sells," he said.
A location with declining sales may remain attractive if margins are strong and servicing costs are low. On the other hand, a high-volume account may be unprofitable if it requires frequent dedicated trips or carries excessive commissions.
For an underperforming account, switching to a smart cooler, larger-capacity machine or different product configuration may improve performance without requiring relocation.
To calculate the location's contribution before equipment costs and overhead, start with gross sales and subtract the cost of merchandise sold, commissions, payment processing fees, inventory losses at purchase cost and direct service expenses. Record discarded inventory once. The amount left should cover equipment costs and overhead and leave a profit.
Evan Lewis advised operators to factor in monthly loan payments and the cost of moving a machine if they leave. In his example, a snack machine that contributes $150 a month after operating costs leaves just $30 after a $120 loan payment. A 10-cent price increase across 400 units sold per month would add $40 in revenue if volume holds, before any increase in sales-based fees. Moving the machine would still involve transport costs, downtime and any remaining loan payments.
That analysis can guide four decisions:
Before you renew, look at what the location leaves you after costs and whether that return is worth the time it takes to service.
Automation is changing how — and where — people shop, eat and access services. The Automated Retail & Kiosk Innovation Show, Dec. 14-16 in Miami Beach, brings together the technologies, ideas and experts shaping the future of self-service and unattended retail.
In addition to writing, Slawsky serves as an adjunct professor of Communication at the University of Louisville and other local colleges. He holds both a Bachelor’s and a Master’s degree in Communication from the University of Louisville and is a member of Mensa and the National Communication Association.