QUICK LINKS: Videos  |  Micromarkets |

Redemption Report




Buy a Classified Ad


Editorial Calendars


Circulation Data






Date Book


Bookmark this site

Issue Date: Vol. 53, No. 4, April 2013, Posted On: 4/3/2013

New York City Appeals Large-Size Soda Ban Ruling

Emily Jed
TAGS: New York City lawyers, NYC soda ban appeal, Bloomberg soda ban, Justice Milton Tingling, sugar-sweetened beverages, National Restaurant Association, American Beverage Association, National Alliance for Hispanic Health, National Association of Local Boards of Health

NEW YORK CITY -- New York City's lawyers have filed an appeal of the decision against Mayor Michael Bloomberg's first-in-the-nation citywide ban of large sugary drinks. The proposed ban, which Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Milton Tingling struck down on March 11 -- a day before it was set to take effect -- would restrict restaurants, movie theaters, delis, stadiums, concession stands and food carts from selling sugar-sweetened beverages in containers larger than 16 fl.oz.

The National Restaurant Association and American Beverage Association were the lead plaintiffs in the lawsuit that challenged the ban.

In his decision, Justice Tingling said the proposed measure was "arbitrary and capricious" because it applied to some, but not all, foodservice establishments. It also exempted certain sweetened drinks, like milk-based coffee beverages, and permitted refills. The judge also stated that the New York City Board of Health had overstepped its authority in passing the ban.

In its brief appealing the decision, filed on April 1, the city defended the ban as a "measured response to a serious health crisis" and argued that its health board has the authority to take measures to protect public health. The city also argued that the judge made "critical" errors in ruling that the ban was "arbitrary and capricious" and that the health board should be allowed to take an incremental approach to regulation rather than be forced to seek a sweeping, all-inclusive ban.

More than 30 health and minority groups have also signed two amicus briefs filed in support of the city's position, led by the National Alliance for Hispanic Health and the National Association of Local Boards of Health. The plaintiffs are slated to file a reply this month.

Topic: Vending Features

  • National Automatic Merchandising Association Discards OneShow Name; The First 'NAMA Show' Takes Place In March 2018
  • Greater Opportunity Awaits In Vending, Coffee And Pantries
  • SandenVendo Adds Ice Vending Machine Using Everest Technology
  • Florida Fresh Vending Acquires Automated Refreshment Services
  • OTI Supplies Cashless Payment Solutions To 365 Retail Markets

Copyright © 2017 Vending Times Inc. All rights reserved. 
P: (516) 442-1850 | F: (516) 442-1849 | subscriptions@vendingtimes.net
55 Maple Ave. - Ste. 304, Rockville Centre, NY 11570